A way to a documentary film by Rudolf Adler

some notions from that book:

A documentarist must know perfectly the subject matter - seeing, experience. (Robert Flaherty - Nanook of the North 1922). The experience is very important. The author's fascination of the subject matter is somehow projected into a form of a documentary. The documentary should evoke the same feeling in audience. It is an essential assumption for an imagination result which should call out catharsis in audience mind (edification, exoneration, relief).

Once an author deeply knows ambient (background) he can structure a theme because the subject matter - seeing reality is not a theme itself. In general, a theme is an author's idea which is formulated on a base of particular observation and experience of subject matter from an artistic point of view. (Robert Flaherty's theme in general: Humanistic theme of human dignity, sociability, solidarity and greatness. Luis Bunuel: His general theme was about human abasement, human dignity humiliation by physical or spiritual affliction etc.)

Both Flaherty and Bunuel fulfil the cathartic process through a strong aesthetic and emotional experience. Besides positive, enjoyable and noble things of the subject matter there should also be those dark, tragic and negative sides of life but it does not mean that the art is negative. (Aristotle and catharsis).

A thematic limitation of art creation within an area of positive life values with a recall on their noble function is a nonsense because the creation loses its philosophy depth and life trueness.

If the theme is an expression of an author's idea in general than the subject is a content concretization.

Exercise: De-edit a sequence - reconnected shots

I was successful to shorten the cuts mainly in shots where no dialogue was and where I was able to play with non-diegetic or off screen sound.

Shots cut down to the absolute bare minimum: I noticed some of them lost their tempo even the cut works well. Some shots have got feeling that something is missing. I was happy when some information was cut out and in the end it was not missing, e.g. Harry gets a coffee. I was not able to cut down some shots because there was a dialogue.

Answer:
1. The sequence still conveys the meaning. It is true that it looks somehow shorten and that something is missing. The flow of the story was damaged and there is a feeling that something must be repaired.

2. The feeling here is that something is missing like tempo and flow of story. The cutting is really important to tell the story to be believable. In my shortened version I cut down 30 second from original which is 4 minutes and 30 s long.

3. I think the feeling did not affected the meaning, still we can feel that Harry is an introvert and professional in his work. The mystery atmosphere is still there.

I did not uploaded the sequence because you-tube blocked some of previous sequences due to the rights.

De-edit a sequence: The Conversation - Motivation for each cut

the first cut: we get all information and the feeling is that Harry is entering the building on the right CUT and we are with him in a lift.

the second cut: Harry is leaving the lift - space of a floor is introduced. A while before a cut we hear "Hi Harry" CUT and we see Harry is taking off his macintosh. The cut works even we saw Harry's back and after the CUT he is standing in front of camera! Motivation: Off Screen Sound ("Hi Harry")

the third: Harry is turning on the equipment and we hear "Listen" CUT and we see his assistant who is reading a part of an article.

the fourth: The assistant is continuing in reading and when he is finishing a movement of scratching his face CUT we see a hand searching photographs. It looks that the CUT works well because there was unfinished movement in the cut before. We see Harry is touching something by his right hand. The scratching movement is not motivation because I tried to cut before the assistant is scratching his face and the CUT worked also. The motivation is maybe a rhythm and we continue to see something what was motivated before. Harry is  looking on photographs.

the fifth: initially I did no notice it but across the CUT we hear "listen this" says assistant CUT and we see Harry is looking down on the photographs. I tried to shorten / prolong the cut but it did not work! It was disturbing cut - there is the off screen sound motivation.

 the sixth: still we can hear the assistant - it is the motivation to make a CUT to see him as he is still reading.

the seventh: The assistant finished the article. After when he rose up his eyes from magazine to Harry, he is looking off screen at Harry and immediately is making a grimace and there is a CUT to Harry's hands searching photographs. Motivation: looking of screen.  I tried to cut after the assistant rose up his eyes and it worked only when the cut was made before the grimace.

the eighth:

the ninth: Off screen motivation - Harry is looking at the photograph - ("Do you want some coffee?" said the assistant in the second frame)

the tenth: Sound off screen - there is a sound of assistant's steps

the eleventh: Stanley is waiting for an answer from Harry - it looks like it was motivation for cut here. Before Stanley started to pour coffee he was looking at Harry but the cut was prolonged. I tried to cut when Stanley is looking at Harry and it worked.

the twelfth: Off Screen Action

the thirteenth: Rhythm 

the fourteenth: Off Screen - Stanley is looking in Harry's position.

the fifteenth: Off screen action, Harry is waiting on beep sound mark on tape to synchronize the three recorders.

the sixteenth:

the seventeenth: Off screen looking

the eighteenth: we can hear the recorded audio and the CUT is motivated by off screen action as Harry is tuning the equipment which controls the three audio players.

the nineteenth: Harry turned off the audio track A and B and tuned only audio track C (City Paris unit) the CUT is motivated by the action.

the twentieth: motivation is probably rhythm because we can see the unit recording the audio and CUT we can see a couple which is recorded.

the twenty-first: we can hear that the recorded audio is loosing its quality CUT and we can see Harry at the desk. I like where the editor made the cut. The couple are hidden behind a figure. The interesting thing is also where the CUT begins - Harry has his eyes closed.

the twenty-second: Cutting on the movement, As Harry is putting his hands on equipment there is CUT to shot which is finishing the movement.

the twenty-third: Harry turned off the track C and tuned up the track A and the CUT is showing us a man who is carrying the unit A - shopping bag.

the twenty-fourth: there is same pattern as it was at the unit C. Harry - Unit - The couple.

the twenty-fifth: the last shot is ending at Harry and CUT we are back at his work.

the twenty-sixth: Harry is looking on the recorder

the twenty-seventh: the motivation is the dialogue

the twenty-eighth: the sound is getting worse, the camera moved from A to B recorder.

the twenty-ninth: the motivation is to show the unit B

the thirtieth: from unit B to the equipment

the thirtieth-first: from the equipment to the photograph

the thirtieth-second: from the photograph to Harry who is looking at it.

the thirtieth-third:  Harry is looking of screen at the recorders

the thirtieth-fourth: Harry is looking off screen at the recorders and after

the thirtieth-fifth: he is looking off screen at loudspeaker

the thirtieth-sixth: we see wide shot and ...........

the thirtieth-seventh: we are going to another sequence